Monday, January 17, 2005

page 74-analysis vs faith

We briefly looked at page 74 in Teaching as Believing on Friday. I had already underlined a passage, and thought that was that. But upon looking at it a second time, a greater understanding (or at least a deeper interpretation) of it became visible.
Page 74: “We can transcend analysis in the act of faith—achieving what Ricouer calls a ‘second naïveté’—or we can refuse to transcend it—remaining on the level of disillusion.”
I love this, because I am in limbo with this constantly; this line of analysis versus faith. I naturally analyze, and often over-analyze. Many things fascinate and baffle me. I am often anxious to figure everything out, to reward my reflections with answers outlined in gold. But not everything can be answered simply from analysis. And maybe part of me doesn’t want everything answered. Because again, there is beauty in being lost, bobbing up and down in the sea of mystery. Sometimes there are things that simply cannot be specifically answered, or even understood. And that’s where faith comes in. I think this is what Ricouer is talking about: this “second naïveté.” This state requires not total naïveté, and certainly not ignorance, but an awareness that some things cannot be explained; that it’s ok to dive into the mystery, to relish in it while it washes over you with refreshing waves of uncertainty. Because there is something exciting about the unexplained, take many peoples’ fascination with aliens, UFO’s, the Lock Ness monster, to name a few.
But often I tell myself that to have faith in the unexplainable is silly, that religion has no more accreditation than a child’s fairy tale. Sometimes I fear I am doomed to eternal disillusionment (but only sometimes, and not that often at that). I struggle. My mind battles with itself; give into the mystery, stick with only what can be empirical proved, back and forth. But the mystery always wins out eventually. Because how can one not trust one’s own emotions if those emotions are continual, powerful, and joyful, emotions so deep that no matter how many times you try to swallow them down, they remain steadfast and clinging to your insides? I know there is a God because I feel it. It’s that simple. Haha, and then there is the Bible and many other ways to back up Christianity, but for me, more than anything else that I have studied or learned about Christianity, simply that I feel it is what brings me the most conviction. Because God’s spirit is flowing within me, I am connected to everything and everyone else through this common God-link. And no matter how much my logical self wants to resist, I cannot deny it.
And so I do transcend. I do reach this second naïveté that Ricouer describes. But once awhile I am compelled to fall away, and in these moments I remind myself that the proof and existence of God is everywhere, even within me. I escape all of the constructions of society and inhale nature in its purity. Analysis is good, but it can only go so far. This is the argument that Ricouer makes. “In the end, after all the analysis, we each have a choice. That our position isn’t necessary means that it’s free.” Indeed, we were born free; we were given free will, we can truly only decide for ourselves. And some may say that I am weak, that to have doubts every once in awhile means that I am not a true Christian. But everyone has to start somewhere. My faith will grow. I have a difficult time putting my entire trust and faith into something, because I have been let down so many times before; we all have. I guess I have just been affected more deeply. And so this is where my hesitation sparks from. But I know that Christianity, God, is so much greater. Transcendence is beautiful. “The struggle is beautiful, I’m too strong for you to slave me” (Talib Kweli).

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home