Sunday, February 13, 2005

beginning Montaigne; learning and teaching

So it’s 2:08am. I should probably be in bed, but I feel oddly awake. Also I’ve totally slacked off today with homework (well with studying), so I’ve decided the least I can do is write a blog. So here I am, still wondrously alive and living. I set out in a lazy tread into these new waters of mystery…
I’ve only just begun my quest with Montaigne. I kind of like the fact that I know next to nothing about him. I bring in no (or at least the minimum) biases or preconceived notions; I honestly don’t think I’ve ever heard of Montaigne before enrolling in this course.
So I’ve only read a few pages (I’m on page 14), and so far Montaigne has mostly talked about education and teaching. Montaigne quotes Cicero, “The authority of those who teach is often an obstacle to those who want to learn” (12).
And, “Our mind moves only on faith, being bound and constrained to the whim of others’ fancies, a slave and a captive under the authority of their teaching” (13).
I like both of these passages. I think authority can be a hindrance sometimes. But I think that authority can also serve as a guide. But authority can only direct someone so far; the pupil has to want to go further to truly succeed I think. And also, if someone has a teacher (an authority figure) whom they do not get along with, then this can be detrimental to the entire realm of learning for a student. Is there a solution to this? Is this clash always the fault of the authoritative figure? I don’t think so. Not every personality is going to mesh with all others. So how does one work around this? Is a sign of a truly “good” teacher one who is able to appease everyone, to present themselves entirely open and agreeable towards everyone? I think this is a bit unrealistic.
In my experience, I have always tended to give my English teachers more leniency than my math teachers for example, because I already enjoy the subject of English. I absolutely loath math, I am horrible at it, and while I do think it a worthy subject of study, I feel I can live a happy and full life without knowing it even half-intimately. But still, I have had some pretty good math teachers, they’re not bad people, but, day after day I would dread their class, because I found the material absolutely boring and irrelevant. So maybe I’ve been lucky.
But I have known people who have had horrible English teachers, and since they already weren’t that interested in the subject, having an inadequate teacher was the last straw for them. And this makes me sad. Because of course, I would love for everyone to give literature a chance, and to find at least some amount of joy in it. I have many non-English major friends; two are pre-vet, one forest rec., one fishery and wildlife, one business, a few engineers, etc. They think I’m crazy to love English. I watched a few of them suffer through writing 121 (I personally never had to take it because I took IB Senior English in high school). Most of my friends became absolutely disillusioned with English because of this course. They would tell me the attitudes of the instructors (ie grad students), and it made me sad to hear what they repeated to me. Granted, even if they had had someone brilliant, I don’t think they would run out and switch their majors to English, but I’d hope that their minds would at least remain open. Now they will always associate English with their bad experiences in their intro to writing course.
“Our mind moves only on faith[…]” I think these few words themselves are beautiful. But then Montaigne goes on to associate faith with captivity. He suggests that faith only goes as far as the faith of the authority. I’m swimming in the mystery, picking and choosing which direction to glide in; it’s my choice, right? Or is our path already lined with invisible bumpers that only allow us to veer of course ever so slightly? But perhaps we are a bit captive under the teacher. If we want to pass our midterm, we have to give the teacher what they want right? The ones who figure that out the best will mostly likely get a higher score than one who writes to his or her own fancy. I don’t usually like being a slave, but there can be some value found in this. I think it is good to be introduced to other ways of learning and thought. This is what happens when you have a variety of authoritative figures; one is introduced to a plethora of styles and methods of teaching, of learning, of thought. And maybe for the term you do have to play their little game, appease them so that you can get you’re A (or at the least a B).
But at the end of the term, you are free again. You can take your newfound knowledge and run with it. You can move on your own faith, no one can hold you to a particular self-creed of thought. Beauty. The world is yours to grasp. Our minds do move on faith. If you do not have any faith or belief in something, than you will not be compelled to follow it, or to take heed of its warnings. Being faithless towards the teacher can be that obstacle that hinders your learning. So what do you do if you ever encounter such a deterrent? You can either resist, thus losing all chance of learning something potentially valuable, or you can put your faith, if not in the teacher, in the process of learning that the teacher is engaging in, so that you may take away at least something worthwhile (if nothing else, the experience of surviving something unpleasant) . You may have to share (or at least go along with) the authority figure’s faith in their teaching process, but this does not indebt you to share their faith in all things. Go ahead, test the un-chartered waters, they may be a bit more salty than you are used to, but the experience will cause you to expand your boundaries.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home